Non-Fiction

Recent Content

Equifax Settlement: An Estimated $95 to $280 for Wrong Credit Scores

Equifax Settlement: An Estimated $95 to $280 for Wrong Credit Scores

About 4 million people are included. Claim by December 28 with the Claim ID and PIN from your notice. The opt-out deadline is November 27.

Read more
The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet

The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet

Sci-Fi Sunday cover quiz: a new clerk joins the crew of a tunneling ship, hoping to leave her past behind. Can you name this Becky Chambers novel?

Read more
Ordinary Grace

Ordinary Grace

William Kent Krueger's Ordinary Grace: a Minnesota boy, a minister's family, and the summer of 1961 when death came to their small town again and again.

Read more
TLDR Don Quixote

TLDR Don Quixote

Don Quixote by Miguel de Cervantes: the whole book in a minute, plus the lines that separate real readers from bluffers at any bar or party.

Read more
The Sympathizer

The Sympathizer

Viet Thanh Nguyen's Pulitzer winning The Sympathizer follows a double agent through the fall of Saigon and exile in Los Angeles. Sharp, dark, and funny.

Read more
See All Content
Plot Digest
  • Fiction
  • Mystery & Thriller
  • Fantasy & Sci-Fi
  • Non-Fiction
  • Other Genres
  • About Us
  • Fiction
  • Mystery & Thriller
  • Fantasy & Sci-Fi
  • Non-Fiction
  • Other Genres
  • About Us
  • ​
The Third Rainbow Girl book cover

The Third Rainbow Girl

by Emma Copley Eisenberg

True Crime
Social Commentary
336 Pages

"Eisenberg's investigation goes far beyond the murders to examine the soul of a community and the myths we tell ourselves about justice."

Synopsis

In June 1980, two young women hiking the Appalachian Trail in West Virginia were brutally murdered at a campsite called Rainbow Falls. The case became known as the Rainbow Murders, and for decades, it remained largely unsolved, leaving a community haunted by questions and suspicion. The Third Rainbow Girl follows journalist Emma Copley Eisenberg as she moves to Pocahontas County, West Virginia, decades later and becomes obsessed with understanding not just who committed these crimes, but why the case has been handled so poorly by law enforcement and the media. Through meticulous research and immersive reporting, Eisenberg uncovers how the murders became a symbol of everything outsiders believe about rural Appalachia—violence, backwardness, and danger. But as she digs deeper, she discovers that the real story is far more complex, involving systemic failures, prejudice, and the way communities cope with trauma. This is both a gripping true crime investigation and a powerful meditation on justice, place, and the stories we tell about both.

Our Take

What sets The Third Rainbow Girl apart from typical true crime narratives is Eisenberg's commitment to examining not just the murders themselves, but the cultural and systemic forces that shaped how they were investigated and remembered. Rather than exploiting tragedy for entertainment, she uses the case as a lens to explore broader questions about rural America, media representation, and the failures of the justice system. Her approach echoes the socially conscious true crime work found in I'll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara and The Fact of a Body by Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich, but with a unique focus on place and community. Eisenberg's background as a fiction writer brings a literary sensibility to the investigation, creating prose that is both beautiful and unflinching. She doesn't just report on West Virginia; she lives there, building relationships and understanding the community from within. This immersive approach results in a book that feels both intimately personal and broadly significant. Perfect for readers who appreciate true crime that grapples with larger social issues and want their investigations served with genuine empathy and insight rather than sensationalism.

Related Content

Non-Fiction

18 November 2026

Post

The Finest Hotel in Kabul

Women Author Wednesday cover quiz: a famed Kabul hotel, a country at war, and the people who passed through its doors. Can you name this Lyse Doucet book?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

17 November 2026

Post

Cave Mountain

True Crime Tuesday cover quiz: a childhood disappearance in the Ozarks, a small town's silence, and a writer's reckoning. Can you name this Benjamin Hale book?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

16 November 2026

Post

Mother Mary Comes to Me

Memoir Monday cover quiz: a celebrated novelist and activist looks back on her mother, her family, and the pull between love and independence. Can you name it?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

13 November 2026

Post

The Library Book

Susan Orlean's The Library Book investigates the 1986 Los Angeles Central Library fire and celebrates the people and places that keep books alive....
Read More

Non-Fiction

11 November 2026

Post

Trick Mirror

Women Author Wednesday cover quiz: nine sharp essays on the internet, reality TV, and the stories we tell ourselves. Can you name this Jia Tolentino book?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

10 November 2026

Post

The Devil in the White City

True Crime Tuesday cover quiz: a grand 1893 world's fair rises in Chicago while a charming killer hides in plain sight. Can you name this Erik Larson book?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

09 November 2026

Post

Open Book

Memoir Monday cover quiz: a famous singer and actress looks back on a childhood in Texas and a career built on grit. Can you name this Jessica Simpson memoir?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

03 November 2026

Post

Furious Hours

True Crime Tuesday: guess the cover of Casey Cep's book about an Alabama preacher accused of murder and the famous novelist who came to watch his trial....
Read More

Non-Fiction

02 November 2026

Post

Born a Crime

Memoir Monday cover quiz: a comedian grows up in South Africa during apartheid, born to parents whose union was illegal. Can you name this Trevor Noah memoir?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

27 October 2026

Post

Story of a Murder

True Crime Tuesday cover quiz: a historian retells a famous 1910 London murder through the women at its center, not the man who made headlines. Can you name it?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

26 October 2026

Post

Between Two Kingdoms

Guess the cover: at 22, a woman is diagnosed with leukemia and must relearn how to live after years spent fighting just to survive, in this Memoir Monday pick....
Read More

Non-Fiction

20 October 2026

Post

Say Nothing

True Crime Tuesday cover quiz: guess the book about a Belfast mother who vanished in 1972 and the long, tangled reach of the Troubles. Can you name it?...
Read More

Non-Fiction

19 October 2026

Post

Crying in the Bathroom

Guess the cover: a Latina writer grows up between cultures, bad dates, and body image battles in this candid Memoir Monday pick....
Read More

Non-Fiction

13 October 2026

Post

Murderland

True Crime Tuesday quiz: guess the cover of Caroline Fraser's investigation linking Pacific Northwest serial killers to industrial toxic pollution....
Read More

Non-Fiction

12 October 2026

Post

The Glass Castle

Guess the cover: a daughter recalls a chaotic, nomadic childhood with brilliant, unreliable parents in this Memoir Monday pick....
Read More
Terms and ConditionsDo Not Sell or Share My Personal InformationPrivacy PolicyPrivacy NoticeAccessibility NoticeUnsubscribe
Copyright © 2026 Plot Digest