Our Take

The Devil at His Elbow represents masterful investigative journalism transformed into compelling narrative nonfiction, showcasing Valerie Bauerlein's exceptional ability to unravel complex webs of corruption and present them in accessible, engaging prose. Her decades of experience as a financial reporter for The Wall Street Journal brings crucial analytical skills to this story, allowing her to follow the money trails and legal machinations that other reporters might miss. The book's strength lies in Bauerlein's methodical approach to documenting not just what happened, but how systemic corruption made these crimes possible over such an extended period. Her work echoes the investigative excellence found in Bad Blood by John Carreyrou and The Power Broker by Robert Caro, but with the immediacy of a case that dominated headlines and captured national attention. Bauerlein's ability to maintain objectivity while clearly conveying the human cost of the Murdaughs' actions demonstrates exceptional journalistic integrity. The book succeeds as both true crime narrative and social commentary, revealing how deeply rooted corruption can poison entire communities and legal systems. Perfect for readers who appreciate thorough investigative reporting, complex criminal cases that involve multiple layers of deception, and anyone interested in how power and privilege can shield people from consequences until the facade finally crumbles. This is essential reading for understanding one of the most shocking legal cases in recent American history.