Our Take

Gilbert's debut thriller excels at exposing the dark underbelly of female friendships, particularly those forged in the intense crucible of university life. The author demonstrates a keen understanding of group dynamics and the way past traumas can fester when left unaddressed. Readers who enjoyed The Guest List by Lucy Foley or Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty will appreciate Gilbert's skill at weaving together multiple perspectives and timelines to reveal the full picture. The isolated island setting creates genuine claustrophobia, while the flashbacks to university days effectively build tension and character depth. Gilbert doesn't shy away from exploring uncomfortable truths about privilege, complicity, and the ways women can wound each other. While some plot elements feel familiar to thriller veterans, the execution is solid and the character development nuanced. The author's background in psychology shows in her authentic portrayal of toxic relationship patterns and trauma responses. Perfect for readers who enjoy psychological thrillers that prioritize character over gore, and for anyone who's ever wondered what would happen if you were trapped with people who knew your worst secrets. She Started It is a promising debut that establishes Gilbert as a writer to watch in the domestic thriller space.