Our Take
One Dark Window announces Rachel Gillig as a major new voice in dark fantasy, combining the atmospheric gothic romance of The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow with the morally complex magic system found in The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang. Gillig's unique card-based magic system feels both fresh and grounded in fairy tale tradition, creating a world where power comes with genuine psychological cost. The enemies-to-lovers romance between Elspeth and Ravyn develops with careful pacing that allows both characters to maintain their individual agency while building genuine connection. Readers who appreciated the dark magic and court intrigue in The Cruel Prince by Holly Black will find Gillig's approach equally compelling, but with more focus on the internal struggle between power and humanity. The novel's exploration of infection, corruption, and the price of magic resonates with contemporary anxieties while maintaining classic fantasy appeal. Gillig succeeds in creating a magic system that feels both wondrous and genuinely dangerous, making every use of power feel consequential. This is essential reading for fantasy fans seeking dark romance with substance, or anyone who appreciates magic systems that reflect the complexity of human nature and the true cost of power.





