Our Take

Borison has crafted a thoroughly modern romance with a delightfully nostalgic twist in this charming story of connection in the digital age. The radio show premise gives First Time Caller a unique flavor among contemporary romances, creating an intimate atmosphere where voices and words take precedence over physical attraction—at least initially. Both protagonists are wonderfully developed with authentic flaws and personal struggles that never feel manufactured for plot convenience. Clementine's introversion and anxiety are portrayed with particular sensitivity, making her gradual emergence from her comfort zone all the more satisfying. Teddy defies the typical "heartthrob with a microphone" stereotype, revealing layers of thoughtfulness and vulnerability beneath his smooth radio persona. The supporting characters—including Clementine's fellow small business owners and Teddy's radio station colleagues—create a warm community backdrop that enhances the central romance. Borison excels at dialogue that crackles with wit while still feeling natural, and the slow-burn development of the relationship strikes just the right balance of tension and sweetness. This is comfort reading at its finest—a gentle, uplifting romance that leaves you with a genuine smile.